Best Roof Shingles Guide

Best Roof Shingles Guide

People often ask us what is the best roof shingle in the market. The answer to this question differs from home to home. Before selecting the ideal roofing shingles for a specific roof, you need to consider every factor.
There are various roof types in various environments, and people have diverse needs and desires for their roofs.
You must consider a few things before deciding on the best roofing shingles: for your home:

Budget

What does your current budget look like? Can you spend the money on the highest-quality roofing shingles right now? Is it worth it? The brands listed below provide the best roofing shingles for every budget.

The most high-performance shingles from any shingle manufacturer typically cost two to three times as much as their least expensive shingles.
The proportion of labor involved in a roofing project can range from 40% to 60%, depending on the specifics of the job. The cost of labor in roofing is not diminished by using cheaper shingles; it is virtually unaffected by material quality.
Reducing material costs is often the approach people take to lower the cost of their new roof. By using the least expensive shingles instead of the most expensive ones, you might save as much as 20% to 30% on your new roof.
A discount on the roof installation could save you thousands of dollars, but it may not be worth saving 25% on a new roof that will only last half as long.
There are many shingle lines offered by the best shingle manufacturers. Of course, using the most expensive or the cheapest shingles is not the only choice, there are choices in between.

Location

Are you concerned about extreme hail where you live? Are you close to the coast or in an area where wind is a problem? You should choose high-quality asphalt shingles with the highest impact or wind resistance ratings.

Future Plans

Is a transferable roof warranty a selling point when trying to sell your home? A new roof will definitely increase the resale value of your home, but there is more to it. Will you keep your house or sell it? In addition to increasing the resale value, a transferable roof warranty will also protect your shingles from future problems.

Appearance

Some manufacturers offer shingles in colors that others don’t. Shingle styles have increased in recent years, and available styles also vary from brand to brand. You’ll want a roof that complements your house.
Look through the shingle options on manufacturers’ websites to find the ideal color and design for your home.

Roof Complexity

Roofs come in different shapes and sizes. Click here to learn all the parts of a roof, what they are called and how they offer functionality to your home. It is highly recommended that you employ a contractor who is accredited by the shingle manufacturer you choose. You should use shingles from a manufacturer that has an accredited contractor certification program.

What are the best roof shingles?

The top shingle manufacturers offer the highest-performance roof shingles. There are several shingle manufacturers who are comparable in terms of experience, quality products, and reputation. All of these manufactures compete with one another on warranty terms, product variety, and prices, among other things.
Most Manufactures fall in line when it comes to adopting new shingle technologies, whether it be algae-free shingles, reflective shingles certified by Energy Star, self-sealing strips, or any other new product. State-of-the-art improvements are continuously being implemented in new products.
We would be pleased to recommend any of these organizations’ roofing shingles, based on the type of roof.
We composed this list of the finest roof shingle manufacturers to get you off to a good start and ensure that you end up using shingles that you can be comfortable with.

Roof Performance

The highest quality roof shingles endure everything the environment can throw at them, including high winds, hailstorms, and constant sun.
A leak-free roof will save you money in the long run by preventing serious damage to your house and its contents. You will also save money by avoiding common roof problems.
The best roof shingles last much longer, often significantly longer. You won’t have to deal with the hassle of having your roof replaced for a very long time if they fail prematurely or unexpectedly, because they will last much longer.
The best roof shingles will cost you less in the long run because they have a lower whole-life cost (or life-cycle cost). The whole-life cost is the total cost of ownership over the life of an asset.

Insurance Discounts

You may save up to 20% on your homeowner’s insurance policy premiums if you have a new roof installed with top-performance shingles from a leading shingle manufacturer.

Resale Value

A roof has a large impact on the value of a house, compared to other home improvement projects. The best roofing material usually provides you with more value for your money when you install a new roof than materials that are cheaper. Investing in a premium roofing material can help you increase the resale value of your home, as well as preserve it.

What do the Best Roof Shingles Have in Common?

When someone gives you their opinion on what the best roof shingles are, personal experience with a company or a preference for a certain style of shingle often plays a big role.
There are, however, some aspects of asphalt shingles that are based on facts and not opinions. These criteria may help you pick the best roof shingle.

Production Quality

The best shingle manufacturers implement industry-best practices to produce high-quality roof shingles, resulting in a consistently satisfactory final product.
How asphalt shingles are manufactured is shown in this brief video:
An asphalt shingle roof that is produced at a high-quality level is less prone to common problems as the roof ages. Manufacturing defects cause common shingle problems such as cupping, clawing, and curling; cracked shingles, lost granules, blisters, and self-sealing adhesive strip failures. Poor manufacturing quality can cause shingles to develop these issues almost as soon as they are installed. However, on old roofs, these issues can often be seen as the shingles near the end of their design life.
It’s true that you won’t be able to see your shingles being made or witness the quality standards being enforced in the factory. One thing you can do is research the manufacturer’s reputation.  A good reputation is the result of decades of producing high-quality products, treating customers well, honoring warranties, and being honest about the limitations and benefits of their products.

Shingle Thickness

A thicker roof covering material will last longer and perform better than a thinner version of the same material. This is true for all types of shingles whether it’s metal, asphalt, etc.

Polymer Modified

The highest quality asphalt shingles use polymer-modified asphalt, also known as “rubberized” asphalt. Polymer-modified asphalt shingles are made in much the same way as modified bitumen roofs for flat roofs, which use 3% to 12% synthetic rubber, and styrene-butadiene-styrene (SBS). It is blended into the asphalt as it is produced. Compared to standard asphalt shingles, polymer-modified ones are better at resisting extreme cold, high winds, and hailstorms as well as being less likely to crack or tear.

Impact Resistance

The level of impact resistance in shingles is determined by how well they stand up to hailstorms. Shingles are rated from Class 1 to Class 4, with Class 4 being the most impact-resistant.
Residential property owners may receive a reduction in their insurance premium by installing a Class 3 or Class 4 impact resistance-relegated roof shingle. The highest impact resistance is typically achieved using polymer-modified shingles.

Fire Rating

Shingles range from Class A to Class C in fire resistance, with Class A providing the greatest defense. The finest roofing materials will have a Class A fire defense rating.

Wind Resistance

High winds can cause serious damage to roofing shingles. Because low-quality shingles are easily torn, cracked, or have their tabs dislodged, this is a big one to keep an eye on if you live in an area with strong winds.
No matter who installs them, the best roof shingles will be covered for wind speeds up to 110 mph right out of the package. A roofing contractor must follow manufacturer-specified installation guidelines if the roof is to survive wind speeds of up to 160 mph. This level of protection is available from a variety of manufacturers, depending on the product line.
There are two standards for measuring the wind resistance of asphalt shingles. Shingles are tested using different procedures and for different performance criteria, and either or both of these standards may be applied to rate them.
The standard method for testing the wind resistance of asphalt shingles (Fan-Induced Method) is ASTM D3161. Shingles are rated as Class A (60 mph), Class D (90 mph), or Class F (110 mph). Class F is the highest rating using the ASTM D3161 standard test method.
ASTM D7158 is the Uplift Force/Uplift Resistance Method. These roof shingles will have a rating of Class D (90 mph),  class G (120 mph), and class H (150mph).  The best wind-resistant shingles will have a wind resistance rating of Class H.
Look for the warranty information on the manufacturer’s website to find the wind resistance information for any particular product. Normally, manufacturers just declare the highest windspeed their shingles can resist (or are warranted to resist).

Warranty

The best manufacturers will offer a non-prorated material warranty for at least ten years. This indicates how confident the manufacturer is that these shingles will perform and keep performing. The best roof shingles offer extended wind speed coverage and warranty options that extend the non-prorated period up to 50 years.

What Shingles Do Roofers Recommend?

All of the roofers we have worked with have a favorite roof shingle manufacturer, and it is usually one of the ones on our list. The reasons they endorse a particular kind of shingle are superior quality, reliability, and performance.
A roofer’s recommendation to use a certain brand of shingle may be based on the fact that he or she has a professional relationship with that company as well. The shingle manufacturers maintain loyalty programs, certify and train roofers, and offer material savings to those who utilize their wares instead of competitors’. They give superior warranties to customers who utilize their preferred roofing contractors. A roofer may receive a discount on shingles and provide extended warranties to entice customers, but this does not imply that they are being deceptive if they suggest a certain brand of shingle.

List of the best Shingle Brands

Manufacturers are listed here in no particular order.

Malarkey

Malarkey-Logo

Malarkey-Logo

Malarkey manufactures asphalt shingles and asphalt shingle accessories, as well as roll roofing products that are closely related.
All of Malarkey’s shingle product lines use high-performance polymer-modified (“rubberized”) asphalt, not just its premium performance shingles. As a result, the lower-end Malarkey shingles are somewhat more expensive than the lower-end shingles from the other manufacturers on this list.
The Malarkey 3-tab shingles are probably the most long-lasting shingles available, thanks to their premium material composition. Again, you get what you pay for.
Despite being one of the smallest companies on this list, Malarkey has one of the best, if not the best, reputations for shingle performance.

IKO

IKO manufactures residential and commercial roofing materials, including asphalt shingle roofing accessories, low-slope modified bitumen roofs, insulation, cover boards, and other low-slope roofing accessories.
When comparing IKO’s product lines to those of other manufacturers, IKO has a reputation as a lower-priced alternative for high-quality roofing shingles. Consumer Reports has consistently rated IKO shingles well and included them on the short list of best roofing shingles.

Owens Corning

Owens-Corning-Logo

Owens-Corning-Logo

Owens Corning produces asphalt shingles and asphalt shingle roofing accessories for residential roofing. In addition to being one of the world’s leading building insulation manufacturers, they also produce a wide range of fiberglass composite materials for a variety of specialty applications.
When it comes to manufacturing, Owens Corning sticks to the highest standards, guaranteeing one of the most generous material warranties in the business.
Owens Corning will provide a 50-year non-prorated warranty on all of the components of your roof, provided that a certified roofing contractor installs it. The labor cost to repair or replace defective materials is covered by the 50-year warranty.

Tamko

TAMKO manufactures residential and commercial roofing materials including asphalt shingles and asphalt shingle roofing accessories, specialty underlayments, modified bitumen rolls, and waterproofing materials.
TAMKO roofing shingles are renowned for their quality and affordability. Despite concentrating on mid and bottom-tier markets for most of the company’s history, they recently began producing premium performance shingles as well.
TAMKO shingles are a sensible choice for roofing shingles if budget is one of your main concerns, despite the fact that they do not offer as many shingle colors and styles as some of the other manufacturers.

Atlas

Atlas manufactures residential and commercial roofing products, including asphalt shingles and asphalt shingle roofing accessories, as well as roofing underlayments and insulation boards.
Atlas offers more colors and styles than most of the other shingle manufacturers. If you can’t find the exact look you want from the other manufacturers, you should look through the shingles available from Atlas.
Many contractors believe that Atlas shingles offer the best value for your money, as they typically cost a bit less than comparable shingles from other manufacturers but perform just as well.
Pinnacle® Pristine is consistently near the top in terms of test performance of Atlas’ most popular shingle line, as evaluated by consumer product evaluators such as Consumer Reports.

CertainTeed

Asphalt shingles and asphalt shingle roofing accessories are among the residential and commercial roofing materials manufactured by CertainTeed. They also produce solar roofing products, vinyl siding, sheathing materials, insulation, and other products with both interior and exterior applications.
While they do not sell as many shingles as GAF, they are still one of the big two, when it comes to the number of shingles sold.
CertainTeed is one of the largest shingle manufacturers, and therefore one of the best-known. Many roofing contractors have relied on CertainTeed shingles for years, and they are happy to tell you why they think they are so good.

GAF

GAF manufactures residential and commercial roofing materials, including asphalt shingles, asphalt shingle roofing accessories, roll roofing, real slate roofing, solar roofing products, ventilation equipment, TPO and PVC single-ply low-slope roof systems, SBS and APP modified bitumen, roof coating materials, and fiber-cement siding. According to GAF,  their Timberline HDZ® line is the most popular line of shingles in North America. GAF sells more shingles than any other manufacturer.
It is not uncommon for roofers to believe that GAF doesn’t possess the same prestigious reputation as CertainTeed, but they almost do, and they also don’t charge as much.
When choosing what shingle manufacturer you should choose, consider the factors listed above. The best roof shingle for your house is the one that has all the features that you are looking for. Use this guide to make the best choice for your home.

Pin It on Pinterest